Advice on HMRC Disclosures and Investigations

Our tax team has over 20 years' experience in supporting clients through voluntary HMRC disclosures and tax investigations. We support our clients with:
  • Advising on how and when you should make a disclosure
  • Identifying the right disclosure route for your circumstances and notifying HMRC on your behalf
  • Assessing how HMRC is likely to classify your behaviour and what that means for penalties
  • Estimate the tax, interest and penalties payable
  • Negotiate with HMRC from first contact to closure

When can HMRC open an investigation?

HMRC has the legal right to look into your books and records at any time. Under Self Assessment legislation, they can investigate taxpayers entirely at random. While it's distressing to receive such a notice, HMRC does not need to provide a reason for looking into you, and they don't even need to suspect anything. In some cases, HMRC will raise what's called an ‘aspect enquiry ', which focuses on one or more parts of your tax return. In others, they may launch a full investigation into all of your tax affairs. The average length of these is around 19 months, and professional fees for managing them often exceed £5,000.

What is a voluntary disclosure?

HMRC can examine a taxpayer's records and can select taxpayers at random under Self Assessment. It does not need a reason or suspicion. An investigation may be an "aspect enquiry" on part of a return or a full review of all of a taxpayer's affairs. Full investigations can run for well over a year, and the professional costs can be substantial. For a Self Assessment return filed on time, HMRC normally has 12 months from the filing date to open an enquiry. It can also make a discovery assessment after that if it finds that tax has been underpaid within the time limits set out below.

What is a voluntary disclosure?

Voluntary disclosure lets taxpayers report underpaid tax and bring their affairs up to date. Benefits include:
  • Lower penalties, especially where the disclosure is "unprompted", meaning you have no reason to think HMRC has discovered or is about to discover the problem.
  • Reduced risk of criminal prosecution
  • Possible room to negotiate a better settlement
We recommend seeking specialist help rather than waiting for HMRC to make contact. Once HMRC has opened an enquiry or contacted you, any disclosure is likely to be treated as "prompted" and the penalty reductions are smaller.

Which disclosure route applies to me?

The right route depends on the type of tax and on how HMRC is likely to view your behaviour.
  • Digital Disclosure Service: for disclosing errors in income tax, capital gains tax, inheritance tax, corporation tax, National Insurance and ATED, whether they arose from honest mistakes, carelessness or deliberate action. It is not used for VAT. You first tell HMRC online that you intend to disclose; HMRC acknowledges the notification and you then normally have 90 days to submit a full disclosure.
  • Contractual Disclosure Facility (COP9): For cases of deliberate tax fraud, HMRC may invite a taxpayer it suspects of serious evasion to use the facility, or a taxpayer can ask to use it voluntarily. To be accepted, you must admit a deliberate failure to report and pay the right tax. If HMRC sends a COP9 notice, a response is required within 60 days.
  • Worldwide Disclosure Facility: For liabilities that relate wholly or partly to an offshore matter. You notify HMRC through the Digital Disclosure Service and have 90 days to complete the disclosure, extendable to 180 days in total for complex cases.
Each disclosure covers one person or company, and the full tax, interest and penalties must be calculated and paid. If you are already under enquiry, HMRC may refer the disclosure to the investigating officer and a higher penalty can apply. This is a specialist area, and we recommend taking advice before notifying HMRC.

What penalties could I face?

Penalties for inaccuracies in returns are a percentage of the extra tax due and depend on your behaviour and on whether you disclose without being prompted. For domestic matters, the percentages are:
  • Careless: maximum 30%. Minimum 0% if the disclosure is unprompted, or 15% if prompted.
  • Deliberate but not concealed: maximum 70%. Minimum 20% if unprompted, or 35% if prompted.
  • Deliberate and concealed: maximum 100%. Minimum 30% if unprompted, or 50% if prompted.
The final percentage depends on the quality of your disclosure, including whether you tell HMRC about the problem, help HMRC work out the tax and give access to records. Penalties for offshore matters are higher and can reach 200% of the tax in the most serious cases. Interest is also charged on unpaid tax from the date it should have been paid.

What are the benefits of a voluntary disclosure?

Voluntary disclosure lets taxpayers report underpaid tax and bring their affairs up to date. Benefits include:
  • Lower penalties, especially where the disclosure is "unprompted", meaning you have no reason to think HMRC has discovered or is about to discover a problem
  • Reduced risk of criminal prosecution
  • Possible room to negotiate a better settlement

How far can HMRC look back?

HMRC can look back up to 20 years in the most serious cases. The time limits depend on the cause of the underpayment:
  • Four years for innocent errors
  • Four years for careless VAT mistakes
  • Six years for other careless mistakes
  • Twelve years for income tax, capital gains tax and inheritance tax where the lost tax involves an offshore matter, or an offshore transfer that makes it harder for HMRC to identify
  • Twenty years for deliberate behaviour with an intention to mislead, a failure to notify HMRC that you are chargeable to tax, and certain undisclosed tax avoidance schemes
An enquiry into a recent matter can widen over time, and if dishonesty is suspected, HMRC can look back up to 20 years.

Who can we help?

We have helped clients disclose undeclared property income, foreign savings and sole trader income. WE can advise on the right disclosure route, calculate tax, interest and penalties, notify HMRC, make the disclosure on your behalf and negotiate the outcome. We deal with HMRC from registration to closure.
It depends on the situation, but HMRC can investigate your affairs as far back as 20 years. Normally, they have 12 months from the date you file your return to open an enquiry if they suspect an incomplete disclosure. After that, they can only investigate if the taxpayer didn’t disclose information they should have. Typical timeframes:
  • Four years for basic or innocent clerical errors
  • Four years for careless VAT mistakes
  • Six years for other careless mistakes
  • Twelve years for offshore income, CGT or inheritance tax irregularities
  • Twenty years for fraud or failure to disclose taxable income without a reasonable excuse
Even if HMRC opens an enquiry for something recent, they can expand it as it progresses. If they believe dishonesty is involved, they can look back up to 20 years. If you’ve had undeclared income from property or side gigs for several years, a simple enquiry could turn into a lengthy investigation.
We have helped a wide range of clients to disclose undeclared property income, foreign savings and sole trade income to HMRC. We can walk you through the full process, talk through your concerns, and provide an estimate of the potential tax, interest and penalties due (if there are any), while handling all dealings with HMRC from registration to closure. If you need support with a disclosure, or have already been contacted by HMRC, please contact a member of our Tax team.